Dr Organic

Dr Organic claims B Corp and Fair Trade certifications but evidence for Fair Trade specificity across botanicals (hero ingredients like organic oils, shea, coconut) is not transparently itemized on public materials—documented direct partnerships with named growers would strengthen P1 by 1–2 points. COSMOS Organic certification on select SKUs is strong (10 pts) but verification that the entire range holds third-party cert (vs. self-declared 'organic') is unclear from website text alone; if range is mixed certified/unverified, P1 ceiling drops to ~22. Formulation: no disclosed concentrations of key actives (e.g., retinol %, niacinamide %, L-ascorbic acid %) and no brand-published clinical trial data limit P2 to 19; formulator pedigree and independent dermatologist endorsement are not publicly named. Packaging: no refill or take-back program documented; significant virgin plastic use likely across range reduces P2 to 16. Aesthetic longevity not yet established (brand age/core-SKU permanence unclear from available text). Recommend: publish INCI + active concentrations for all hero SKUs, third-party certify full range (not just select products), detail Fair Trade supplier partnerships by name, and introduce refill or mail-back option.